...

Infrastructure Debt: An Outsized Contribution in a Dislocated World

Share on Linkedin
Share on Twitter
Share on Facebook
Share on Whatsapp

By Rene Kassis, Co-Managing Partner, CIO Infrastructure Debt at CAERUS Debt Investments – CapMan and Laurence Monnier, Senior Adviser Infrastructure Debt at CAERUS Debt Investments – CapMan  as published in Insight/Out magazine #39.     

Often overlooked for its modest headline return, Infrastructure Debt may be the most capital-efficient tool available to institutional investors – provided the portfolio is viewed as a whole.

The allocation challenge

Investors are navigating a fast-evolving environment in which traditional strategic asset allocation (SAA) is increasingly being challenged: Equities remain the mainstay of most portfolios and have delivered strong returns over the past decade. But the asset class carries growing concentration risk, by region (US) and by sector (technology), leaving it increasingly exposed to sharp corrections. Bonds, traditionally the second-largest allocation, have seen their diversification benefit erode.

Real assets offer a natural response, and investors typically look to the largest segments: Real Estate, Infrastructure, Private Equity and Private Debt. Within that universe, Infrastructure Debt is often treated as a niche – or passed over because of its lower headline return. That is a missed opportunity. Yet the asset class offers distinctive diversification benefits and can make an outsized contribution to a portfolio’s risk-adjusted returns.

Built for stress

Infrastructure Debt rides the same tailwinds as Infrastructure at large – above all, Europe’s push toward a cleaner, more energy-independent economy. With roughly 70-80% of Infrastructure investment needs funded by debt, and banks’ capacity to lend increasingly constrained, the opportunity set is substantial across the capital stack – from senior through subordinated, mezzanine and HoldCo structures – allowing investors to dial in precisely the risk-adjusted return profile they want.

The asset class has also proven itself through the cycle. Rating volatility is materially lower than for corporate debt of comparable seniority, particularly in periods of economic crisis.[1]

image 2

Recoveries after default are higher too: around 80% on average, according to Moody’s project finance default study.[2] That resilience feeds straight into performance. A recent SIPAmetrics study finds that its Infrastructure Debt indices have delivered risk-adjusted returns exceeding Bloomberg’s corporate equivalents by 13% for investment grade – and by 41% for non-investment grade.[3]

Insurers noticed these benefits early. EIOPA´s own data show that insurers’ Private Credit exposure – a category that explicitly includes Infrastructure Debt alongside non-listed corporate bonds and Real Estate and mortgage-related loans – reached €514 billion, or 5.1% of total assets, at the end of 2024. This scale of commitment has been reinforced by the lower capital charges applied to qualifying Infrastructure Debt and equity under Solvency II. Pension funds and other institutional investors, however, have been slower to follow. Without a dedicated allocation bucket, many simply overlook the asset class, often citing returns that look “below target” on a standalone basis.

A different approach to portfolio construction

Traditional SAA frameworks allocate capital into discrete buckets, with funds competing for room against peers within each one. Under this approach, Infrastructure Debt typically fights for space inside a broader “Infrastructure” or “Private Debt” allocation – a structure that captures neither the full diversification and return benefit of the asset class, nor the distinct characteristics of the funds within it.

A growing number of investors have recognized this limitation and adopted a total portfolio approach (TPA), evaluating each investment on its marginal contribution to the existing portfolio rather than its fit within a predefined bucket. TPA can replace or supplement SAA -and it appears to pay in optimizing portfolio construction. A survey of 26 large funds using TPA found that they outperformed peers using traditional SAA[4]. By shifting the burden of proof onto each asset’s marginal contribution to the whole portfolio, this approach makes the case for Infrastructure Debt considerably clearer.

Lower headline return, highest contribution

Infrastructure Debt exhibits negative correlation with both bonds and equities, generating incremental income at minimal capital cost. That income profile becomes even more attractive as the asset class extends beyond core senior financing into subordinated debt and the financing of “growth Infrastructure” – corporate borrowers with solid Infrastructure characteristics that are earlier in their development. Infrastructure floating rate loans, with their shorter duration, also exhibit lower volatility than bonds

Taking a TPA lens, we compared the marginal contribution of different debt strategies to a standard 60/40 equity/bond portfolio. We modelled a BB/B-rated Infrastructure loan portfolio (70% floating rate) consistent with a growth-Infrastructure strategy, benchmarked against two public-market comparators (investment-grade corporate debt and high-yield debt) and two other high-yielding Private Debt strategies: direct lending, and Real Estate Debt at approximately 70% LTV.

We deliberately kept the analysis conservative. Rather than taking full credit for Infrastructure Debt’s negative correlation, we floored each asset class’s correlation to equity at 25%. The analysis also incorporated Infrastructure Debt’s lower volatility and expected loss using Moody’s default studies.

The result is striking: Infrastructure Debt offers by far the most attractive return per unit of risk. Notably, the gross return we modelled for Infrastructure Debt is the lowest among the Private Debt strategies compared – yet its marginal contribution to the portfolio is the highest. In our analysis[5], the return per marginal capital of Infrastructure Debt was three times higher than the next best asset.[6] At a time when rising volatility is pushing up portfolio risk, the asset class so often overlooked for its modest headline return has the potential to deliver the greatest marginal contribution to portfolio income per euro of capital deployed.

image

The bottom line

The Infrastructure Debt market is broadening, offering an ever-wider range of risk and return profiles just as Europe’s financing needs – driven by its push for sovereignty and energy independence – continue to grow.

For pension funds and other long-horizon institutional investors managing portfolios in an increasingly volatile environment, the conclusion is hard to ignore: judged not by its headline return but by what it adds to the whole, Infrastructure Debt offers a compelling tool for optimizing the total portfolio.


[1]Moody’s Ratings, Infrastructure Default and Recovery Rates 1983-2024, September 2025.

[2]Moody’s, Default and Recovery Rates for Project Finance Bank Loans, 2022

[3]SIPAmetrics, The Performance of Infrastructure Debt, June 2026. Comparison of SIPA infrastructure debt indices against Bloomberg corporate bond equivalents.

[4] FF TAI – AO Peer Study

[5] Sources: MSCI EUR investment grade and high yield indices, Morningstar European Leveraged loan index, ishare EUR high yield corporate bond, Gilberto-Levy commercial Real Estate debt index, SIPA Infra300 debt Index, Cliffwater Corporate Lending Fund, Nuveen “The enduring case for high yield bonds”, 2018, Invesco “Navigating volatility through Allocation to real estate equity and debt”, Sep 25, EDHECInfra “Strategic asset allocation with unlisted infrastructure”, 2021, and authors estimates.

[6] Assumptions as follows for IG bonds, high yield bonds, direct lending, sub-IG real estate debt, sub IG infrastructure debt: Gross return: 3%, 5.5%, 8.5%, 8.5%, 7%, correlation with bonds 0.85, 0.56, 0.09, -0.43, -0.10, correlation to equity 0.51, 0.60, 0.5,-0.1,-0.3, volatility 4%, 3.5%, 3%, 5%, 1.4%

BIL_AIF_WEBSITE_(250x250)
Website_Banner_ATOZ_LPEA_250x250px
Fundequate_Website banner 250x250

Response to the AMLA Public Consultation

Response to the European Commission Targeted Consultation on Private Equity Exits